English as a Second Language (ELL)
The Effect of a Cognitive Model, Thinking Maps, on the Academic Language Development of English Language Learners
By Estrella López, St. John Fisher College, August 2011
This study describes how teachers of two urban suburban schools with large numbers of English language learners (ELLs) used Thinking Maps as a cognitive model resulting in student's improved academic language development. Teachers used Thinking Maps that included a common cognitive language that transcended grade levels and disciplines.
An antecedent condition for these results was school-wide professional development of teachers' expertise using Thinking Maps. Teachers' anecdotal reports and samples of student work gave evidence to this researcher's hypothesis: participating schools that implemented cognitive visual tools improved the academic language development of all their students.
A phenomenological methodology was used to guide a descriptive qualitative study. Interviews and a survey served as the instruments for collecting data to gain insight into the factors that support teachers' capacities to influence ELLs' development of academic language.
Findings of the study revealed a conceptual framework: a Model for Full Access for High Achievement in which five essential components describe the successful use of Thinking Map to teach ELLs.
The research provides recommendations for administrators and teachers regarding the application of the Model for Full Access for High Achievement. A whole-school approach for teachers utilizing a common, cognitive tool proved significant in supporting ELLs, one of the most vulnerable sub-groups of students pressured to perform by the challenges of Common Core Standards.
The study concludes that additional research (e.g., longitudinal studies, mixed populations etc.) needs to be conducted on the efficacy of Thinking Maps to improve academic achievement among ELLs, as well as students with special needs and struggling learners.
Download the dissertation The Effect of a Cognitive Model, Thinking Maps, on the Academic Language Development of English Language Learners (Acrobat PDF file)
Thinking Maps®: Strategy-Based Learning for English Language Learners (and Others!)
Stefanie Holzman Principal, Roosevelt Elementary School, Long Beach, CA + Pamell Gallagher - Olive Elementary School, Sonoma, CA
Aiming High, Sonoma County, January 2006
“Thinking Maps are invaluable for pre-writing. I am able to quickly assess whether students have understood a concept or learned key information by glancing at their completed maps.”
“Thinking Maps are an important strategy for student success. They help all children, whether their primary learning style is kinesthetic, auditory, or verbal. It’s a very good strategy for English Language Learners because it takes away the necessity to speak and write English.”
Download the article Thinking Maps®: Strategy-Based Learning for English Language Learners (and Others!) (Acrobat PDF file).
Roosevelt Elementary School
New Rochelle